Difference between revisions of "Template:Did you know nominations/42nd Floor Apartment"

From blackwiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>LavaBaron
imported>Spinningspark
(reviewed: good to go)
Line 21: Line 21:
 
:*'''Comment:''' This is not a review, but I have a question about this article's title. Do any reliable sources refer to the apartment as the "42nd Floor Apartment"? If not, then there may be an issue with [[WP:NAMINGCRITERIA]], which states that {{tq|"titles are based on how reliable English-language sources refer to the article's subject"}}. It may be better to rename the article something like "Waldorf Residence of the United States Ambassador to the United Nations" (the title used by the [http://hospitalitybusinessnews.com/20150622645/us-diplomats-leave-the-new-york-waldorf-astoria Hospitality Business News]) or the "Official Residence of the United States Ambassador to the United Nations" (adopted from [http://www.cbsnews.com/news/new-un-ambassadors-perk-a-nyc-penthouse/ CBS's description] of the penthouse as the "official residence of America's Permanent Representative to the U.N."). Otherwise, this is a very interesting article. Best, -- [[User:Notecardforfree|Notecardforfree]] ([[User talk:Notecardforfree|talk]]) 22:06, 28 October 2015 (UTC)
 
:*'''Comment:''' This is not a review, but I have a question about this article's title. Do any reliable sources refer to the apartment as the "42nd Floor Apartment"? If not, then there may be an issue with [[WP:NAMINGCRITERIA]], which states that {{tq|"titles are based on how reliable English-language sources refer to the article's subject"}}. It may be better to rename the article something like "Waldorf Residence of the United States Ambassador to the United Nations" (the title used by the [http://hospitalitybusinessnews.com/20150622645/us-diplomats-leave-the-new-york-waldorf-astoria Hospitality Business News]) or the "Official Residence of the United States Ambassador to the United Nations" (adopted from [http://www.cbsnews.com/news/new-un-ambassadors-perk-a-nyc-penthouse/ CBS's description] of the penthouse as the "official residence of America's Permanent Representative to the U.N."). Otherwise, this is a very interesting article. Best, -- [[User:Notecardforfree|Notecardforfree]] ([[User talk:Notecardforfree|talk]]) 22:06, 28 October 2015 (UTC)
 
:::Good points. I've moved the page to the first title you suggested. [[User:LavaBaron|LavaBaron]] ([[User talk:LavaBaron|talk]]) 06:08, 29 October 2015 (UTC)
 
:::Good points. I've moved the page to the first title you suggested. [[User:LavaBaron|LavaBaron]] ([[User talk:LavaBaron|talk]]) 06:08, 29 October 2015 (UTC)
 +
 +
[[File:Symbol confirmed.svg|16px]] New enough, long enough, within relevant policies, hook length ok, interesting enough and cited. 
 +
 +
A couple of comments though, unrelated to DYK.  With the current title the article should (or at least could in principle) include the official residences of ambassadors before the Waldorf Astoria was used in the history section.  Also the change of title is not reflected in the navbox, which is now showing a bluelink.  Secondly, the picture does not actually include the 42nd floor apartment as it only shows the lower floors.  There are ones available that do, [[:File:St Bartholomews and The Waldorf Astoria Hotel.jpg]] for instance. [[User:Spinningspark|<b style="background:#FAFAD2;color:#C08000">Spinning</b>]][[User talk:Spinningspark|<b style="color:#4840A0">Spark</b>]] 22:37, 1 November 2015 (UTC)
  
 
}}<!--Please do not write below this line or remove this line. Place comments above this line.-->
 
}}<!--Please do not write below this line or remove this line. Place comments above this line.-->

Revision as of 22:37, 1 November 2015

42nd Floor Apartment

Created by LavaBaron (talk). Self-nominated at 03:00, 28 October 2015 (UTC).

  • Comment: This is not a review, but I have a question about this article's title. Do any reliable sources refer to the apartment as the "42nd Floor Apartment"? If not, then there may be an issue with WP:NAMINGCRITERIA, which states that Template:Tq. It may be better to rename the article something like "Waldorf Residence of the United States Ambassador to the United Nations" (the title used by the Hospitality Business News) or the "Official Residence of the United States Ambassador to the United Nations" (adopted from CBS's description of the penthouse as the "official residence of America's Permanent Representative to the U.N."). Otherwise, this is a very interesting article. Best, -- Notecardforfree (talk) 22:06, 28 October 2015 (UTC)
Good points. I've moved the page to the first title you suggested. LavaBaron (talk) 06:08, 29 October 2015 (UTC)

Symbol confirmed.svg New enough, long enough, within relevant policies, hook length ok, interesting enough and cited.

A couple of comments though, unrelated to DYK. With the current title the article should (or at least could in principle) include the official residences of ambassadors before the Waldorf Astoria was used in the history section. Also the change of title is not reflected in the navbox, which is now showing a bluelink. Secondly, the picture does not actually include the 42nd floor apartment as it only shows the lower floors. There are ones available that do, File:St Bartholomews and The Waldorf Astoria Hotel.jpg for instance. SpinningSpark 22:37, 1 November 2015 (UTC)