Difference between revisions of "Template:Disputed tag"

From blackwiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>WOSlinker
(ombox)
imported>David Levy
(repaired code; switched to dedicated shortcut box to enable changes to the original without affecting this template; moved documentation to subpage)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
{{ombox
 
{{ombox
| type     = other
+
|type = notice
| image     = [[Image:Red question mark.svg|30px]]
+
|image = [[Image:Red question mark.svg|30px]]
| text     = {{#if:{{{1|}}} | {{shortcut|{{{1|}}}|{{{2|}}}|{{{3|}}}|{{{4|}}}|{{{5|}}} }} }} '''{{#ifeq:{{lc:{{{section|}}}}}|yes|The following section's wording or inclusion in this|This page's designation as a}} [[Wikipedia:Policies and guidelines|policy or guideline]] is [[Wikipedia:Dispute resolution|disputed]] or under discussion.''' Please see the relevant discussion on the [[{{{talkpage|{{TALKPAGENAME}}#{{ucfirst:{{{talk|}}}}} }}}|talk page]] for further information. {{{msg|}}}
+
|text = '''{{#ifeq:{{lc:{{{section|}}}}}|yes|The following section's wording or inclusion in this|This page's designation as a}} [[Wikipedia:Policies and guidelines|policy or guideline]] is [[Wikipedia:Dispute resolution|disputed]] or under discussion.''' Please see the relevant discussion on the [[{{{talkpage|{{TALKPAGENAME}}#{{ucfirst:{{{talk|}}}}} }}}|talk page]] for further information. {{{msg|}}}
 +
|imageright = {{#if:{{{1<includeonly>|</includeonly>}}} | {{Ombox/Shortcut|{{{1|}}}|{{{2|}}}|{{{3|}}}|{{{4|}}}|{{{5|}}} }} }}
 
}}<noinclude>
 
}}<noinclude>
 
+
{{documentation}}<!-- Add categories and interwikis to the /doc subpage, not here! --></noinclude>
----
 
'''Note: The use of this tag on policy and guidelines by itself can be controversial and is likely to spark an edit war.'''
 
 
 
*Optionally specify:
 
** Either, a talk page section: <code><nowiki>{{</nowiki>Disputedtag|talk=Discussion}}</code> will link "talk page" to Talk:PageName#Discussion.<br />
 
** Or, a full page-link: (usually to a centralized talk-page) <code><nowiki>{{</nowiki>Disputedtag|talkpage=Talk:MyPage#Discussion}}</code> will link "talk page" to Talk:MyPage#Discussion.<br />
 
** If the tag applies strictly to a specific section of a policy or guideline, append the following parameter: <code>section=yes</code>
 
** A short message about what to do instead -- for editors lacking time to analyze the current discussion: <code>msg=''the default recommendation''</code>
 
** Up to 5 [[Wikipedia:Shortcut|Shortcut-links]], as described for  [[Template:Shortcut]].
 
 
 
 
 
*When adding this template, do not remove the policy or guideline tag, first because otherwise users cannot see what the dispute is about, and second because a dispute does not automatically revoke the policy or guideline. See [[WP:POL]] for details.
 
*This template is only for ''ongoing, active disputes'' that are evidenced in talk page discussion. It is not intended for flagging a projectpage or section as vaguely controversial, nor for indicating a personal dislike of the document.  There is no such thing as an indefinitely disputed policy or guideline.
 
*For disputes about the ''wording'' of the policy or guideline (as opposed to the "designation", what this template says), use {{tl|underdiscussion}} instead. Disagreement over the wording of a policy or guideline does not imply it is suddenly not a policy or guideline any more. See [[WP:POL]] for details.
 
*If you disagree with a {{tl|historical}} tag, do not use this template; instead, advertise the page on e.g. [[WP:RFC]] and the [[WP:VP|village pump]] to get more people involved, so that it becomes active once more.
 
 
 
For related [[:Category:Wikipedia header templates|Wikipedia header templates]]
 
see [[Wikipedia:Template messages/Project namespace|Template messages/Project namespace]].
 
 
 
[[Category:Wikipedia header templates|{{PAGENAME}}]]
 
[[Category:Dispute templates|{{PAGENAME}}]]
 
</noinclude>
 

Revision as of 10:51, 23 July 2008

Template documentation[view] [edit] [history] [purge]

Template:Template notes

When to use

  • Use this template to dispute whether a page (or a section on a page) has properly been accorded policy or guideline status.
  • This template is only for ongoing, active disputes that are evidenced in talk page discussion. It is not intended for flagging a project page or section as vaguely controversial, nor for indicating a personal dislike of the document. There is no such thing as an indefinitely disputed policy or guideline. These tags should not be used as a badge of shame. If there is no active discussion, then the tag may be removed by any editor. For more information on the proper use of this tag, see WP:Policies and guidelines.

How to use

  • Place {{Disputed tag}} at the top of the page or section that you intend to discuss.
  • Optionally specify:
    • Either, a talk page section: {{Disputed tag|talk=Discussion}} will link "talk page" to Talk:PageName#Discussion.
    • Or, a full page-link: (usually to a centralized talk-page) {{Disputed tag|talkpage=Talk:MyPage#Discussion}} will link "talk page" to Talk:MyPage#Discussion.
    • A short message about what to do instead -- for editors lacking time to analyze the current discussion: msg=the default recommendation
    • Up to 5 Shortcut-links, as described for Template:Shortcut.
    • If the tag applies strictly to a specific section of a policy or guideline, append the following parameter: section=yes . This will cause the template to appear as:
  • When adding this template, do not remove the policy or guideline tag, first because otherwise users cannot see what the dispute is about, and second because a dispute does not automatically revoke the policy or guideline. See WP:POL for details.

Alternatives

  • Many times, your concerns can be addressed through a normal discussion, without placing this tag on the page.
  • For proposals to change policies or guidelines, use {{Under discussion}} instead (see that template's page for available options). If the proposal concerns a page's status as policy or guideline, use {{Under discussion|status}}.
  • If you disagree with a {{Historical}} tag, do not use this template; instead, advertise the page on e.g. WP:RFC and the village pump to get more people involved, so that it becomes active once more.

For related Wikipedia header templates, see Template messages/Wikipedia namespace.

uk:Шаблон:Під сумнівом