1980: White | 1981: Nettles | 1982: Lynn | 1983: Boddicker | 1984: Gibson | 1985: Brett | 1986: Barrett | 1987: Gaetti | 1988: Eckersley | 1989: Henderson | 1990: Stewart | 1991: Puckett | 1992: Alomar | 1993: Stewart | 1994: Series Not Played | 1995: Hershiser | 1996: Williams | 1997: Grissom | 1998: Wells | 1999: Hernández | 2000: Justice | 2001: Pettitte | 2002: Kennedy | 2003: Rivera | 2004: Ortiz | 2005: Konerko | 2006: Polanco | 2007: Beckett | 2008: Garza | 2009: Sabathia |